Understanding Separation of Duties (SoD) in Identity Governance

Read full article here: https://claritysecurity.com/clarity-blog/what-is-sod/?source=nhimg

In the ever-evolving digital landscape, organizations are grappling with heightened risks to sensitive data and critical systems. Separation of Duties (SoD) stands as a foundational principle in Identity Governance and Administration (IGA) to mitigate fraud, ensure compliance, and safeguard operations. If you're searching for "what is Separation of Duties" or how SoD can protect your business, this guide dives deep into its history, importance, examples, regulations, failures, and implementation strategies—optimized for today's hybrid environments.

A Brief History of Separation of Duties

The roots of SoD trace back to ancient civilizations like Rome and Greece, where dividing powers prevented corruption. In the 18th century, French philosopher Montesquieu formalized the "division of powers" concept, influencing modern governments' checks and balances.

In business, SoD surged in prominence after the early 2000s scandals like Enron and WorldCom, prompting the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) in 2002. This legislation mandated robust internal controls, including SoD, for financial reporting, IT security, and more. Fast-forward to 2025, SoD remains vital amid rising cyber threats and regulatory scrutiny.

What Is Separation of Duties (SoD)? Definition and Core Principles

Separation of Duties (SoD) is a risk management strategy that divides critical tasks and responsibilities among multiple individuals or departments. This prevents any single person from gaining unchecked control over processes, reducing opportunities for fraud, errors, or misuse.

In IT and identity management, SoD ensures users don't hold conflicting access rights—such as approving and executing the same transaction—that could breach security or compliance. By enforcing "checks and balances," SoD aligns with the least privilege principle, making it a cornerstone of modern IGA systems.

Why Is Separation of Duties Important? Key Benefits

Implementing SoD delivers multifaceted advantages:

• Risk Mitigation: Distributes tasks to curb fraud, insider threats, and human errors by requiring multiple approvals for high-risk actions.
• Compliance: Meets stringent regulatory demands, avoiding penalties and building trust with stakeholders.
• Operational Integrity: Enhances process accuracy and reliability, minimizing disruptions.
• Auditability: Creates clear accountability trails for easier tracking and investigations.

In 2025, with remote work and hybrid clouds prevalent, SoD is essential for defending against sophisticated attacks.

Regulations Requiring Separation of Duties Controls 

SoD isn't optional, it's mandated or recommended by numerous frameworks. Here's a updated list of key SoD regulations:

These align with SoD principles, even if not always explicitly named. In 2025, updates like ISO 27002:2022's Control 5.3 emphasize SoD to combat evolving threats.

Common Separation of Duties Policy Examples

Effective SoD examples span industries:

1. Financial - One person initiates payments; another approves them.
2. IT - Developers code, but can't deploy to production without review.
3. Procurement - Separate roles for creating purchase orders and approving vendors.
4. HR - Hiring managers recruit; finance sets salaries.
5. Access Management - Users request access; approvers grant it—never self-approving.

These policies prevent overreach and promote accountability.

Real-World Examples of SoD Failures: Lessons from History 

Neglecting SoD can lead to catastrophic outcomes. Here are notable SoD failure examples, including recent cases:

• Enron Scandal (2001) - Executives hid debt via off-books entities; lack of SoD enabled manipulation.
• Société Générale (2008) - Trader caused €4.9B loss; front/back-office SoD breaches allowed hidden trades.
• Barings Bank (1995) - Trader's dual execution/settlement roles led to £827M loss and collapse.
• Wells Fargo (2016) - Fraudulent accounts from poor sales/account SoD.
• Wirecard (2020) - Executives' unchecked control hid €1.9B fraud.
• JPMorgan "London Whale" (2012) - $6B+ loss from inadequate risk SoD.
• Toshiba (2015) - $1.2B inflated profits due to weak executive oversight.
• Volkswagen (2015) - Emissions cheating from SoD lapses in development/compliance.

These underscore that SoD lapses can devastate any organization, emphasizing proactive enforcement.

Key IGA System Capabilities for Supporting SoD

Modern IGA systems empower SoD with:

1. Role Mining and Management: Analyze access to create non-conflicting roles.
2. SoD Rule Definition: Customize and enforce policies.
3. Workflows: Multi-step approvals aligned with SoD.
4. Continuous Monitoring: Real-time violation alerts.
5. Reporting/Analytics: Insights into risks.
6. Automated Remediation: Fix conflicts swiftly.

Considerations Before Implementing an IGA/SoD Solution

Plan strategically:

1. Define Policies - Tailor to business and regs.
2. Engage Stakeholders - Involve IT, security, compliance.
3. Evaluate Tech - Ensure integration.
4. Phased Rollout - Start with high-risk areas.
5. Manage Change - Address resistance.
6. Continuous Improvement - Build adaptable processes.

Common Challenges in Implementing SoD in Hybrid Environments

Hybrid setups pose hurdles:

1. Lack of Documentation: Undocumented legacy systems hinder mapping.
2. Technical Limits: Inadequate granular controls lead to workarounds.
3. Integration Issues: Inconsistent SoD across platforms.
4. Resource Constraints: Overburdened staff in smaller teams.
5. Skill Gaps: Concentrated expertise complicates separation.

How Clarity Security Simplifies Separation of Duties Implementation

Clarity Security revolutionizes SoD policy enforcement with universal visibility into accounts and entitlements. Here's how:

• Tag-Based Policies - Create SoD tags for entitlements; manage each policy separately.
• Automatic Violation Tagging - Refresh identities to flag breaches instantly.
• Dedicated SoD Reviews - Audit exceptions with approval trails.
• Custom Reports - Track SoD-related changes for audits.

With Clarity, tagging entitlements enforces SoD effortlessly, freeing you to focus on growth. Discover how Clarity can streamline your SoD strategy.

By mastering what is Separation of Duties, organizations can fortify defenses, achieve compliance, and drive efficiency. Stay ahead of risks, implement SoD now for a secure future. For more on IGA trends, subscribe to our blog!