Responsibility for online fraud losses is moving away from victims alone and onto the platforms that host scam adverts and the payment firms that move the money. In the UK, the Online Safety Act 2023 gives the largest platforms and search engines specific duties on fraudulent advertising, and the Payment Systems Regulator (PSR) requires most authorised push payment (APP) scam victims to be reimbursed, with costs split between sending and receiving firms. In the EU, a provisional deal on a new Payment Services Regulation would make banks refund certain impersonation scams and make online platforms liable to banks when they fail to remove reported fraudulent content. This map sets out scope, obligations, status, enforcement and practical compliance steps for fraud, payments, trust and safety and security leads. Status was checked on the official sources listed on 27 October 2026; these regimes are still changing, so confirm the current position before relying on any detail.
Key takeaways
- UK reimbursement is live. Since 7 October 2024, in-scope payment firms must reimburse APP scam victims for Faster Payments and CHAPS payments up to £85,000 per claim, with the cost shared 50:50 between the sending and receiving firm.
- UK platform fraud advertising duties are being switched on. Ofcom published the register of categorised services on 10 July 2026 and is consulting on the fraudulent advertising duties for Category 1 and 2A services; final policy statements are due by mid-2027 at the latest.
- The EU deal is agreed but not yet law. The European Parliament announced a provisional agreement on the Payment Services Regulation in November 2025; as of 27 October 2026 the procedure was awaiting formal adoption, with an indicative plenary date of 14 December 2026.
- Liability follows the weakest link. Under both regimes the firm that could have stopped the fraud, whether by better monitoring, payee checks or ad removal, is increasingly the one that pays.
- Automation must be evidenced. Platforms must explain proactive technology used against fraudulent ads, and payment firms rely on automated monitoring; the models, bots and service accounts behind these controls are now part of what regulators examine.
Regulations and frameworks at a glance
| Regime | Jurisdiction | Who it applies to | Core fraud duty | Status (27 October 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Online Safety Act 2023, section 38 | UK | Category 1 user-to-user services | Prevent users encountering fraudulent adverts, minimise time present, take down swiftly | In law; register published 10 July 2026; Ofcom consulting on codes |
| Online Safety Act 2023, section 39 | UK | Category 2A search services | Same aims for fraudulent adverts in or via search results | In law; legislation.gov.uk shows in force from 10 January 2024; duties being operationalised by Ofcom |
| PSR APP scams reimbursement requirement | UK | Payment service providers handling in-scope Faster Payments; CHAPS via the Bank of England | Reimburse APP scam victims, share cost 50:50 between sending and receiving firms | Live since 7 October 2024; maximum £85,000 per claim |
| EU Payment Services Regulation (procedure 2023/0210(COD)) | EU | Payment service providers; online platforms; some electronic communications providers | Payee name checks, refunds for bank-impersonation fraud, platform liability to PSPs | Provisional agreement November 2025; awaiting formal adoption |
Scope: who and what is covered
UK Online Safety Act fraudulent advertising duties
- Services: section 38 applies to providers of Category 1 services and section 39 to Category 2A search services. Which services fall into each category is set by Ofcom's register of categorised services, published on 10 July 2026 after a representations process in spring 2026.
- Content: under section 39(3) an advert is "fraudulent" if it is a paid-for advertisement and amounts to an offence specified in section 40 of the Act. Organic posts by users are handled under the illegal content duties instead.
- Territory: both sections apply only to the design, operation and use of the service in the United Kingdom (sections 38(7) and 39(7)).
- Search carve-out for combined services: section 38(6) says the Category 1 duties do not cover fraudulent adverts in search results of a combined service; those are handled under the search duties.
UK PSR reimbursement requirement
- Payments: APP scam payments made by Faster Payments or CHAPS between UK accounts. The Bank of England, as CHAPS operator, set the same £85,000 maximum for CHAPS claims.
- Firms: all payment service providers that handle in-scope funds, including payment initiation service providers, according to the PSR's June 2023 policy overview.
- Exclusions: the PSR's policy overview lists first-party fraud and gross negligence as exclusions, with gross negligence and the excess not applied to vulnerable customers. Private civil disputes fall outside the scheme; PSR guidance (PS24/6) helps firms separate them from scams.
EU Payment Services Regulation (provisional)
- Payment service providers: banks, payment institutions and e-money institutions offering payment services in the EU.
- Online platforms: according to the European Parliament, the deal makes platforms liable to PSPs that have reimbursed defrauded customers where the platform was informed of fraudulent content and did not remove it, extending the Digital Services Act approach.
- Advertisers of financial services: must show very large online platforms and search engines that they are authorised, or exempt, to offer those services.
- Electronic communications providers: the Parliament says the regulation applies to them in some cases; the detailed duties will only be clear in the adopted text.
Key obligations
| Regime | Obligation | Source |
|---|---|---|
| OSA s.38 | Use proportionate systems and processes to prevent individuals encountering fraudulent adverts, minimise how long they are present, and swiftly take them down when alerted or otherwise aware | Section 38(1) |
| OSA s.38 | Explain in terms of service any proactive technology used to comply | Section 38(2) |
| OSA s.39 | Equivalent duties for fraudulent adverts in or via search results, plus a publicly available statement on proactive technology | Section 39(1) and (2) |
| OSA s.38 and s.39 | Proportionality takes account of the nature and severity of harm and the provider's degree of control over ad placement | Sections 38(5) and 39(6) |
| PSR | Reimburse in-scope APP scam victims, normally within five business days, with a stop-the-clock provision for further information | PSR June 2023 overview; PSR APP scams page |
| PSR | Share the reimbursement cost 50:50 between sending and receiving PSP | PSR APP scams page |
| PSR | Accept claims made up to 13 months after the last payment; reimburse up to £85,000 per claim | PSR June 2023 overview; PS24/7 |
| EU PSR (provisional) | Check that the payee name matches the account identifier and refuse the payment and inform the payer on a mismatch | European Parliament press release |
| EU PSR (provisional) | Treat transactions initiated or altered by a fraudster as unauthorised, with the PSP liable for the full amount; refund the full amount where a scammer posing as PSP staff tricks a customer, if the customer reports to police and the PSP | European Parliament press release |
| EU PSR (provisional) | Offer spending limits and blocking measures; freeze suspicious incoming transactions at the receiving PSP; give users access to human customer support, not only chatbots | European Parliament press release |
Timeline and current status
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| May 2022 | HM Treasury announces intention to legislate so the PSR can require APP scam reimbursement |
| June 2023 | Financial Services and Markets Act 2023 receives Royal Assent; PSR policy statement PS23/3 |
| December 2023 | PSR policy statement PS23/4 finalises remaining points |
| 10 January 2024 | Online Safety Act section 39 shown in force on legislation.gov.uk |
| 23 April 2024 | European Parliament adopts its first reading position on the Payment Services Regulation |
| 2 October 2024 | PSR PS24/7 confirms £85,000 maximum per claim |
| 7 October 2024 | UK APP scams reimbursement requirement goes live |
| August 2025 | Legal challenge to the UK categorisation thresholds concludes |
| November 2025 | European Parliament announces provisional agreement on the Payment Services Regulation (press release dated 27 November 2025) |
| 5 May 2026 | European Parliament committee approves the agreed PSR text |
| 10 July 2026 | Ofcom publishes the register of categorised services and opens consultations, including one on fraudulent advertising duties for Category 1 and 2A services |
| End of September 2026 | Ofcom consultations close |
| October and November 2026 | Category 1 and 2A services provide risk assessment records to Ofcom, then publish summaries |
| 14 December 2026 (indicative) | European Parliament plenary listed for the Payment Services Regulation |
| By mid-2027 at the latest | Ofcom final policy statements on additional duties for categorised services |
The EU application dates will be set in the final adopted text. The PSR said it would keep the £85,000 level under review as part of its evaluation of the policy. The government has announced plans to consolidate the PSR into the Financial Conduct Authority, so check which body currently owns and enforces these rules.
Enforcement and penalties
- Online Safety Act: Ofcom can impose penalties of up to the greater of £18 million or 10% of the provider's qualifying worldwide revenue for its most recent complete accounting period (Schedule 13, paragraph 4).
- PSR reimbursement: the PSR runs a compliance and monitoring regime for Faster Payments participants (PS24/3) and publishes reimbursement data, including an APP scams reimbursement dashboard. The financial consequence for firms is the reimbursement cost itself, split between sender and receiver.
- EU Payment Services Regulation: enforcement will rest with national competent authorities once the regulation applies; the main commercial exposure is the shift of liability for losses to PSPs that fail to prevent fraud and, through recovery claims, to platforms that do not act on reports.
What it means for AI agents and non-human identities
- Proactive technology is a regulated control: platforms must describe proactive technology used against fraudulent adverts. The classifiers, ad review bots and their service accounts become part of the compliance evidence: document what they do, who owns them and how they are changed.
- Automated monitoring decides liability: under the EU deal a PSP that fails to implement appropriate fraud prevention covers the loss. Transaction monitoring models, payee name checks and freeze automation run on service identities and API keys that need least privilege, change control and logging. See the Transaction Monitoring and Behavioural Biometrics Guide.
- Human support is required: the Parliament says the EU deal gives users access to human customer support, not only chatbots. Firms using AI agents in fraud and dispute handling need a clear escalation path to people.
- Agent-initiated payments: where an AI agent initiates a payment, firms need records of the customer's mandate and the agent's identity to decide whether a payment was authorised. See the Agent Payments Protocols Guide.
- Impersonation at scale: deepfake voices and AI chatbots are used to pose as bank staff, the exact case the EU deal makes PSPs refund in full. See the Spotting Deepfake Scams Guide.
Compliance steps
- Confirm which regimes apply: check Ofcom's register for your services, whether you send or receive in-scope UK payments, and your EU payment and platform footprint.
- Map fraud flows to duties: for each regime, list the controls that meet each obligation, their owners and the evidence they produce.
- Platforms: build the advert pipeline: advertiser verification (especially for financial services), pre-publication screening, user reporting, fast takedown and metrics on time-to-removal; document proactive technology for terms of service or public statements.
- Payment firms: tune for liability: payee name checks, risk-based friction and warnings, inbound monitoring for mule accounts, and claim handling within the five business day target. See the Authorised Push Payment (APP) Fraud Guide.
- Set up cross-sector reporting: agree how platforms receive fraud reports from payment firms and how payment firms evidence that a platform was informed, since EU recovery claims will depend on it.
- Govern the automation: inventory the models, bots and service accounts used in fraud controls, with owners, change logs and access reviews.
- Track change: monitor Ofcom consultations and statements, PSR publications and the EU adoption process, and update the map when final texts appear.
Common failure patterns
- Treating takedown as the only duty: the Online Safety Act duties also require prevention and minimising exposure time, not just removal after reports.
- Receiving firms ignoring inbound risk: with a 50:50 split, a receiving PSP that does not detect mule accounts pays half of every claim it could have stopped.
- Losing the evidence trail: without records of reports sent to platforms, or of what an automated control decided and why, firms cannot defend decisions or recover losses.
- Planning on draft EU text: the agreed text is not yet adopted; building systems around press-release detail risks rework when the final text appears.
- Misclassifying cases: first-party fraud and civil disputes are outside UK reimbursement, but treating genuine victims as either causes harm and regulatory risk. See the First-Party Fraud Guide.
Practitioner checklist
- Check Ofcom's register of categorised services and record whether your services are Category 1 or 2A.
- Document proactive technology used against fraudulent adverts and where it is described publicly.
- Measure time from fraudulent advert report to removal.
- Confirm UK reimbursement processes meet the five business day target and the 13 month claim window.
- Monitor inbound payments for mule activity as a receiving firm.
- Prepare for EU payee name verification and bank-impersonation refunds once the final text is adopted.
- Keep evidence of fraud reports sent to and received from platforms.
- Inventory and govern the models, bots and service accounts that run fraud controls.
- Review this map against official sources at least quarterly.
Standards and references
- legislation.gov.uk: Online Safety Act 2023, section 38
- legislation.gov.uk: Online Safety Act 2023, section 39
- legislation.gov.uk: Online Safety Act 2023, Schedule 13
- Ofcom: Roadmap to regulation
- Payment Systems Regulator: APP scams
- Payment Systems Regulator: PS24/7 APP scams reimbursement, confirming the maximum level
- European Parliament: Payment services deal, more protection from online fraud and hidden fees
- European Parliament Legislative Observatory: Procedure 2023/0210(COD)
This guide summarises UK and EU online fraud regulation for security and fraud practitioners and is not legal advice; confirm obligations with your legal and compliance teams and the primary texts. Related NHI Mgmt Group resources: Authorised Push Payment (APP) Fraud Guide · PSD2/PSD3 Strong Customer Authentication Guide · Fraud and Cyber Convergence Guide · Consumer Reporting Routes Map