TL;DR: 693% year over year shows how quickly genAI traffic to U.S. retail sites grew in the 2025 holiday season, per SEON's telemetry data. Fraud scoring now has to weigh identity context and payment risk more heavily than session behaviour.
Editorial analysis by NHI Mgmt Group, based on content published by SEON: “Why Agentic Checkout Moves Fraud Detection Back to the Identity Layer”.
By the numbers:
- Traffic to U.S. retail sites from genAI tools rose 693% year over year during the 2025 holiday season.
- Shoppers arriving via AI assistants converted at a rate 31% higher than other traffic sources.
Key questions
Q: Why do verified agents still need customer-level fraud checks?
A: Because an agent can be authenticated while the person behind it remains fraudulent, stolen or synthetic.
Q: What are the warning signs that agentic traffic is being used for retail fraud?
A: Look for one device, identifier or session hitting many cards, accounts or promo codes in a short window, especially if the values rise or the redemptions arrive at machine-like intervals.
Q: How should fraud teams score agentic checkout without relying on human behaviour?
A: They should move the primary decision away from session cues and toward identity evidence that survives automation.
Practitioner guidance
- Reweight fraud models toward pre-session identity evidence Reduce reliance on mouse movement, typing cadence and form timing for automated checkout flows, and increase the weight of email reputation, phone quality, device history and payment context.
- Separate agent trust from customer trust Use signed requests or protocol checks to confirm the agent, then run a second decision layer on the human account, payment method and identity history behind the transaction.
- Hunt for machine-speed promotional abuse Look for one identifier, device or session touching many accounts, cards or redemptions in a short period, especially where the cadence is too consistent for human activity.
Bottom line: Agentic checkout weakens the value of classic behavioural fraud signals because software can now produce a convincing session without a human at the keyboard.
Glossary terms: Agentic Checkout, Digital Footprint Monitoring, Agent Trust Registry, Behavioural fraud signal
Explore further
View Full Forum → | NHI Foundation Course → | Our Services → | Read the full analysis →
Agentic checkout does not remove fraud signals, it relocates them. The behavioural layer becomes less reliable, but the identity layer remains intact and still carries most of the loss. That means fraud governance has to stop treating session human-ness as the core question and start treating customer trustworthiness as the core question. Merchant teams should rebase their models on identity evidence that exists before the session begins.
A few things that frame the scale:
- Nearly 60% of companies reported that fraud losses were still increasing in 2025.
A question worth separating out:
Q: Should merchants prioritise identity history over behavioural analytics for AI-assisted checkout?
A: Yes, where agents materially change the session pattern. Behavioural analytics still help, but identity history becomes the more durable discriminator when software handles the interaction. Merchants should prioritise the signals that persist when cursor movement, typing cadence and timing are no longer trustworthy indicators of intent.
👉 Read our full editorial: Agentic checkout shifts fraud detection from behavior to identity