TL;DR: Misread claims data, policy terms, and fabricated statistics have helped fuel the belief that cyber insurance does not pay claims, according to Coalition. Retention levels, limits, and response services shape whether coverage ends in indemnity or loss avoidance.
Editorial analysis by NHI Mgmt Group, based on content published by Coalition: “Dispelling the Myth That ‘Cyber Insurance Doesn't Pay Claims’”.
By the numbers:
- Coalition paid more than $315 million in claims in 2025 alone.
- Just 26% of cyber insurance claims in 2025 were closed with indemnity payments, according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners research cited by Coalition.
Key questions
Q: Why do payout percentages in cyber insurance reports often look lower than buyers expect?
A: Because payout percentages mix together different retentions, limits, incident severities, and open claims.
Q: What signs show that a cyber claims statistic is misleading?
A: Watch for a figure with no primary source, no methodology, or no clear definition of what counts as a paid claim.
Q: How should organisations evaluate cyber insurance if many claims close without an indemnity payment?
A: They should judge the policy on the full response it enables, not only on cash indemnity.
Practitioner guidance
- Scrutinise claims data provenance Require primary sources, methodology, and date context before accepting any cyber claims statistic in broker conversations or board papers.
- Separate indemnity from response value Assess whether a policy can fund containment, forensics, and legal support even when a loss does not exceed the retention.
- Recalculate retention and limit assumptions Review whether your current retention reflects deliberate risk transfer or an accidental underinsurance position based on incident severity.
Bottom line: The article argues that cyber insurance scepticism is often driven by misread claims data, not by a simple absence of payment.
Glossary terms: Retention, Indemnification, Claims Closed Without Payment, Risk Transfer
Explore further
View Full Forum → | NHI Foundation Course → | Our Services → | Read the full analysis →
Claims payment should be evaluated as a response system, not as a simple payout ratio. The article correctly shows that a closed claim with no indemnity can still represent successful intervention through investigation, containment, and legal support. That matters because cyber loss is often suppressed before it becomes a balance-sheet event. Practitioners should stop equating zero payout with zero value.
A question worth separating out:
Q: How can brokers explain a cyber policy’s value before a loss becomes a payout problem?
A: They should show how reporting triggers, response services, retention thresholds, and limit caps work together in a real incident. That helps clients understand that cyber insurance is part of incident handling as well as financial recovery, which is the distinction most objections miss.
👉 Read our full editorial: Cyber insurance claims myths obscure how coverage actually responds