TL;DR: Return abuse can fully fit policy and still erode retailer margin, SEON reports, so finance and fraud teams often miss the loss. Return controls need shared review before refunds clear, or the cost stays hidden across stores, e-commerce and marketplaces.
Editorial analysis by NHI Mgmt Group, based on content published by SEON: “Return Fraud Is a Margin Problem, Not a Security Problem”.
By the numbers:
- Returns fraud now accounts for nearly 14% of all U.S. returns and costs retailers roughly $103 billion in 2024.
- SEON’s 2026 Fraud & AML Leaders Report surveyed 1,010 fraud, risk and compliance leaders.
- Return fraud and promo or discount abuse each ranked as a top threat for 18% of respondents.
Key questions
Q: Why do return policies create margin risk even when customers follow the rules?
A: Because policy-compliant behaviour can still be economically abusive.
Q: What are the signs that return abuse is becoming a measurement problem?
A: The clearest sign is when fraud teams and finance teams report different pictures of the same loss.
Q: How should retailers decide when a return request needs manual review?
A: Retailers should route a return to manual review when identity, device or behavioural signals do not fit the customer’s normal pattern, especially when the value or frequency of returns is unusual.
Practitioner guidance
- Align finance and fraud on one loss metric Tie return reason, customer risk, shipping cost, restocking cost and margin impact into one reporting view so abuse is not hidden across separate dashboards.
- Apply risk-based review before refund issuance Use device, email, phone, loyalty and order-history signals to decide whether a return should be auto-approved, routed to review or blocked before cash leaves the business.
- Segment return policies by risk profile Reserve stricter rules for serial returners, suspicious marketplaces and repeated high-risk behaviour, rather than applying identical terms to every customer.
Bottom line: Return abuse can be fully policy-compliant and still create substantial margin loss, which is why it often escapes traditional fraud ownership.
Glossary terms: Return Fraud, Margin Leakage, Wardrobing, Behavioural Signal
Explore further
View Full Forum → | NHI Foundation Course → | Our Services → | Read the full analysis →
Return abuse is a governance problem, not just a fraud problem. The article shows that organisations often treat post-purchase abuse as an operations issue because the customer is following policy rather than breaking into a system. That distinction matters because governance fails when ownership is split between finance, fraud and store operations. The practitioner takeaway is to treat policy abuse as a measurable control gap, not a miscellaneous loss bucket.
A few things that frame the scale:
- 92% of organisations expose NHIs to third parties, raising concerns about supply chain security, according to the Ultimate Guide to NHIs.
A question worth separating out:
Q: Who should own refund fraud when it spans finance, fraud and operations?
A: Ownership should sit with a shared governance model, not a single silo. Fraud teams, finance leaders and operations all see different parts of the loss, so the practical answer is a cross-functional process with one escalation path, one reporting view and one decision standard for high-risk returns.
👉 Read our full editorial: Return abuse is a margin leakage problem, not just fraud loss