TL;DR: Generic security maturity scoring can mislead identity teams when it is not anchored to actual control evidence and ownership, according to Netwrix. PolicyPak-style assessments need a closure workflow, or the score never shows whether IAM, PAM, or NHI risk is actually being reduced.
Editorial analysis by NHI Mgmt Group, based on content published by Netwrix: “GPOs einheitlich und zentral verwalten mit PolicyPak”.
Key questions
Q: Why do generic maturity scores fail identity governance programmes?
A: They often flatten distinct control domains into one score, which hides where the real exposure sits.
Q: How should security teams use an IAM maturity assessment in practice?
A: They should use it to find where identity governance is fragmented, not to produce a vanity score.
Practitioner guidance
- Define an identity governance baseline first Inventory human accounts, privileged accounts, service accounts, and other non-human identities before using any maturity benchmark.
- Split benchmark results by control domain Separate IAM, PAM, and NHI findings instead of collapsing them into one overall maturity score.
- Attach each gap to a named owner Require every benchmark finding to include a control owner, a remediation target, and a closure date.
Bottom line: Generic maturity benchmarking can mislead identity teams if it is not anchored to actual control evidence and ownership.
Glossary terms: Identity Governance, Security Maturity Metrics, Control ownership
Explore further
View Full Forum → | NHI Foundation Course → | Our Services → | Read the full analysis →
Security maturity is only credible when it is anchored to identity control evidence. Broad benchmarking can be useful for executive framing, but it becomes misleading when it is detached from the controls that actually reduce access risk. In practice, IAM, PAM, and NHI programmes need evidence chains, not just scores. The practitioner conclusion is simple: measure the control estate first, then compare maturity.
A question worth separating out:
Q: What should teams do when a maturity assessment reveals control gaps?
A: Assign each gap to a named control owner, define the target state, and put it into a closure workflow. The purpose of assessment is to create accountable remediation. If the finding does not change ownership or drive a fix, the benchmark has not improved governance.
👉 Read our full editorial: Security maturity benchmarks show the limits of generic assessment