Join our Newsletter — 33% off our NHI Course
Home› Guides› Security Programme Maturity Assessment Template: Self-Assessment Worksheet Across…
Template Security Leadership & Governance

Security Programme Maturity Assessment Template: Self-Assessment Worksheet Across CSF 2.0

PDF for newsletter subscribers · free to read online

← All guides
By NHI Mgmt Group, edited by Lalit Choda Updated 27 October 2026 9 min read
On this page

Security programme self-assessments often produce a single maturity number that nobody can explain, defend or act on, because the scale, evidence rules and scope were never written down. This template gives you a repeatable worksheet across the six NIST CSF 2.0 Functions (Govern, Identify, Protect, Detect, Respond and Recover) and their 22 Categories, with a defined five-level maturity scale, evidence requirements, a target-setting step and a results summary for leadership. It uses the CSF 2.0 Tiers (Partial, Risk Informed, Repeatable, Adaptive, from NIST CSWP 29 published 26 February 2024) as a cross-check on how risk is governed and managed, rather than as the score itself. It is written for CISOs, GRC leads and internal assessors running an annual or pre-investment self-assessment. For the maturity concepts behind it see the GRC Maturity Model; for subcategory-level Current and Target Profiles use the CSF 2.0 Organisational Profiles Template.

How to use this template

  • Replace text in square brackets, such as [Organisation], [Assessment lead] and [Scope], with your own values.
  • Assess at Category level for a programme view (22 Categories). Drop to Subcategory level only where a Category scores low or matters most; that detail belongs in an Organisational Profile.
  • Agree the scale and evidence rules in sections 3 and 4 before any interviews. Changing them mid-assessment invalidates comparisons.
  • Set the target level for each Category from risk and requirements, not from what seems achievable.
  • Repeat with the same scale each year so results show trend. Keep the completed worksheet and evidence index as the audit trail.

1. Assessment scope and context

FieldEntry
Assessment ID and date[SPMA-2026-01, DD Month YYYY]
Purpose[Annual baseline / board request / pre-budget / post-incident / regulatory preparation]
Scope[Whole organisation / business unit / critical service]
Exclusions and rationale[For example OT environment assessed separately]
Previous assessment[ID and date, or "first assessment"]
Frameworks referenced[NIST CSF 2.0; optionally ISO/IEC 27001:2022, CIS Controls v8.1]

2. Assessment team and participants

RoleResponsibilityName
SponsorCommissions the assessment, receives results, approves targets[Name]
Assessment leadPlans, runs workshops, applies the scale consistently, drafts the report[Name]
Category respondentsDescribe current practice and supply evidence[One owner per Category]
Calibration reviewerSamples evidence and challenges scores before results are final[Second line or internal audit]

A self-assessment is only as credible as its challenge step. Where possible, have someone outside the Security Function review a sample of scores.

3. Maturity scale

LevelNameDescription
0AbsentNo activity addressing the Category
1InitialActivity happens ad hoc, depends on individuals and covers part of the scope
2DevelopingActivity is planned and partly documented; applied in some areas or inconsistently
3DefinedApproved policy and procedures exist and are applied across the scope, with named owners
4ManagedPerformance is measured against targets, reviewed regularly and corrected when it drifts
5OptimisedPractice improves continuously from metrics, lessons learned and threat changes, and is automated where sensible

Use whole numbers. If a Category sits between two levels, score the lower and record what is missing in the gap column.

4. Evidence rules

  • Level 1 and 2: respondent description plus at least one example (ticket, email, report).
  • Level 3: approved policy or standard, procedure, named owner, and sample records showing it is applied across the scope.
  • Level 4: level 3 evidence plus metrics with targets, at least two reporting periods of results, and records of corrective action.
  • Level 5: level 4 evidence plus documented improvements made from metrics or lessons learned in the last 12 months.
  • Evidence age: evidence older than 12 months does not support level 3 or above.
  • No evidence: the score is capped at 1 regardless of the description.

5. Self-assessment worksheet

Score each Category. The prompts are starting questions; add your own. Record the evidence reference so the calibration reviewer can sample it.

FunctionCategoryAssessment promptCurrent (0 to 5)TargetEvidence refKey gap
GovernGV.OC Organizational ContextAre mission, stakeholders and legal and contractual requirements documented and used in risk decisions?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
GV.RM Risk Management StrategyIs there an approved risk appetite and a standard method for rating cyber risk?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
GV.RR Roles, Responsibilities, and AuthoritiesAre security roles, authority and resources defined and approved, for example in a programme charter?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
GV.PO PolicyAre policies approved, communicated, reviewed and enforced?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
GV.OV OversightDoes leadership review security performance and adjust strategy?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
GV.SC Cybersecurity Supply Chain Risk ManagementAre suppliers tiered, assessed and monitored according to risk?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
IdentifyID.AM Asset ManagementAre hardware, software, cloud services, data and identities inventoried with owners?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
ID.RA Risk AssessmentAre vulnerabilities, threats and impacts assessed and recorded in a register?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
ID.IM ImprovementAre improvements identified from assessments, tests, exercises and incidents and tracked?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
ProtectPR.AA Identity Management, Authentication, and Access ControlAre human and non-human identities managed, strongly authenticated and given least privilege?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
PR.AT Awareness and TrainingDo staff and privileged users receive role-based training with measured effect?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
PR.DS Data SecurityIs data classified and protected at rest and in transit, with tested backups?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
PR.PS Platform SecurityAre configurations hardened, software maintained and logs generated?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
PR.IR Technology Infrastructure ResilienceAre networks segmented and capacity and resilience planned?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
DetectDE.CM Continuous MonitoringAre networks, endpoints, cloud, identities and suppliers monitored for adverse events?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
DE.AE Adverse Event AnalysisAre alerts correlated, triaged and escalated to incidents against defined criteria?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
RespondRS.MA Incident ManagementIs there an approved, exercised incident response plan with third parties?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
RS.AN Incident AnalysisAre investigations, root cause and evidence preservation performed?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
RS.CO Incident Response Reporting and CommunicationAre regulators, customers and stakeholders notified on time?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
RS.MI Incident MitigationCan incidents be contained and eradicated quickly, including credential revocation?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
RecoverRC.RP Incident Recovery Plan ExecutionAre recovery plans tested and restoration integrity verified?[ ][ ][ ][ ]
RC.CO Incident Recovery CommunicationIs recovery progress communicated to stakeholders?[ ][ ][ ][ ]

For PR.AA, score human and non-human identities separately if their practices differ; service accounts, API keys and AI agents are often one or two levels behind workforce identity. The NHI Risk Scoring Guide helps scope that population.

6. Tier cross-check

After scoring, check the overall picture against the CSF 2.0 Tiers. CSWP 29 describes them as a progression from informal, ad hoc responses to approaches that are agile, risk-informed and continuously improving, and encourages progression to higher Tiers when risks or mandates are greater or a cost-benefit analysis supports it.

TierGovernance and management characteristics (CSWP 29, summarised)Typical worksheet pattern
1 PartialAd hoc governance; case-by-case management; limited awareness of supplier riskMost Categories at 0 to 1
2 Risk InformedManagement approves practices but not organisation-wide policy; informal information sharingGovern at 2, others mixed 1 to 2
3 RepeatablePractices approved as policy and reviewed; organisation-wide approach; supplier risk formally acted onMost Categories at 3, Govern at 3 or above
4 AdaptiveRisk management part of culture; practices adapt from lessons and predictive indicators; near real-time supplier risk informationMost Categories at 4 to 5

If the worksheet suggests level 4 across Protect but the Tier cross-check suggests Tier 2, scores are probably inflated or Govern is lagging. Revisit evidence before reporting.

7. Results summary and priorities

FunctionAverage currentAverage targetLargest gap CategoryChange since last assessment
Govern[ ][ ][ ][ ]
Identify[ ][ ][ ][ ]
Protect[ ][ ][ ][ ]
Detect[ ][ ][ ][ ]
Respond[ ][ ][ ][ ]
Recover[ ][ ][ ][ ]

List the top five improvement priorities, each with owner, deadline and the risk scenario it reduces. Report Function averages only alongside the Category detail; an average hides a single weak Category such as RS.MA that could dominate loss. See the Board Cyber Risk Reporting Guide.

8. Sign-off and next assessment

  • Calibration complete: [reviewer name, date, number of scores changed].
  • Approved by: [sponsor name, date].
  • Next assessment due: [date, normally 12 months], or earlier after a major incident, acquisition or reorganisation.

Implementation guidance

  1. Plan (weeks 1 to 2): confirm scope, scale and evidence rules with the sponsor; send respondents the worksheet and evidence list in advance.
  2. Collect (weeks 2 to 5): run one 60 to 90 minute workshop per Function; respondents score first, the lead challenges against the evidence rules.
  3. Calibrate (week 6): the reviewer samples at least [20] percent of scores at level 3 or above and adjusts where evidence is missing.
  4. Report (week 7): results summary, top priorities and Tier cross-check to [Security governance committee].
  5. Act and track: feed priorities into the roadmap and budget; link each to an Organisational Profile action where one exists.

Small organisations can complete the worksheet in two half-day sessions with an external facilitator; score at Function level first, then Category level for Govern and Protect. Large organisations should run the template per business unit with a shared calibration reviewer, then compare units rather than averaging them.

Useful measures: percentage of Categories at or above target; number of scores changed at calibration (high numbers mean the scale is unclear); evidence age; year-on-year change per Function; and priorities delivered by their deadline.

Common failure patterns: averaging all 22 Categories into one number for the board; letting respondents set their own targets; accepting level 3 or 4 without metrics; assessing only technical Functions and skipping Govern; and repeating the assessment with a changed scale so trends are meaningless.

Template sectionNIST CSF 2.0NIST SP 800-53 Rev. 5
1 Scope, 3 Scale, 4 EvidenceGV.RM-06CA-2 Control Assessments
5 WorksheetID.IM-01CA-2, CA-7 Continuous Monitoring
7 Results and prioritiesGV.OV-03, ID.RA-06PM-6 Measures of Performance, PM-4 Plan of Action and Milestones Process
8 Sign-offGV.OV-01PM-9 Risk Management Strategy

Standards and references

This template is provided for guidance and must be adapted to your organisation. Related NHI Mgmt Group resources: GRC Maturity Model · CSF 2.0 Organisational Profiles Template · NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 Guide · C2M2 Cybersecurity Capability Maturity Model Guide · Security Programme Charter Template

PDF for subscribers

Take this guide with you

Every section, table and checklist in one PDF, with links to the sources and related guides. Subscribe to our weekly NHI & AI Identity Journal and we’ll email you a download link.

Free weekly newsletter

Subscribe to the NHI & AI Identity Journal

The latest on NHI and Agentic AI security – articles, research, breaches, news and events every week.

Bonus 33% off our NHI Course when you subscribe.

NHIMG Editorial Note
Researched and written by the NHI Mgmt Group editorial team using AI tools, under the editorial direction of Lalit Choda. Facts are drawn from the sources listed on this page and checked by our automated quality process. Last updated 27 October 2026. Spotted an error? Use our contact page.
NHI Mgmt Group, the independent authority on Non-Human Identity, IAM and Agentic AI security. nhimg.org

PDF Downloads for Newsletter Subscribers

Get the guide

Enter your details and we’ll email you a download link.

The full guide is free to read online. The PDF is a thank you for subscribing.

Fill in all fields marked * and tick the PDF box to continue.